To test whether these "no price increase" HDB flats will be popular, all we need to do is conduct a simple experiment.
Go to Marine Parade and ask Granny Yeo and Grandpa Sharma whether they are willing to return their HDB flats to Mah Bow Tan for $100,000.
If they say "YES!!! YES!!! Free rental for 35 years!!! Worthless in another 15 years!!! Take it back! Take it back!!! Give me $100,000!!! HOORAY!!!" ... then the scheme will be workable.
The Straits Times
Scenic drive
HDB flats with great views are in hot demand.
Tay Suan Chiang
Sat, Jun 23, 2007
Madam Yeo Wee Geck on her 20th-storey Marine Parade unit. She can catch the sunrise as well as enjoy the sea view from her flat.
Mr Chris Koh, director of Dennis Wee Properties, says prices for private properties have soared over the past year due to the influx of investment from foreigners and buyers' confidence in the Singapore economy.
And that has also boosted the demand for HDB flats in good locations and on higher floors.
He cites the example of a five-room HDB flat in Marine Parade that has unblocked views of the sea. He says that, three years ago, it would have fetched about $350,000.
"A year ago, it could sell for $400,000. Today, buyers are willing to pay $500,000," he says.
But even though their flat may now fetch a higher price, some home owners are unwilling to sell.
Housewife Yeo Wee Geck, 85, is one. The grandmother of six lives with her only daughter and their maid in a five-room HDB flat in Marine Parade. She bought the 20th-storey unit in the early 1970s for $30,000.
She gets to watch the sun rise from her flat, as well as enjoy views of East Coast Park and the sea. "It is so breezy here. I won't move out," she says.
Block 29 Marine Crescent. RETIREE P.R. Sharma, 81, has a view from his 20th-storey flat that many Singaporeans would envy.
His five-room HDB point-block flat overlooks East Coast Park and the city skyline in the distance. He can even see the sea from a side window and from the bedroom and living room.
He gets to enjoy the sunrise from his flat, watch planes land and take off from nearby Changi airport and count the number of tankers dotting the sea off East Coast Park.
He paid $35,500 for the flat in 1974, and says he was offered about $900,000 for it nearly 20 years ago. Property agents say the current selling rate for such a flat is $500,000.
He adds that even if he was offered $1million today, he would not sell it. He gets about three flyers a day from agents looking for sellers but he throws them in the bin without even looking at them.