U.S. Jobless Claims Hit New Pandemic Low as Employers Retain Workers

Initial filings for unemployment benefits fell to 310,000 last week

Sept. 9, 2021

Filings for jobless benefits last week fell and reached a pandemic low, extending a downward trend as demand for labor remains high and employers hold onto workers despite the Delta variant of Covid-19.

Initial unemployment claims, a proxy for layoffs, moved lower in the week ended Sept. 4 to 310,000 from a slightly upwardly revised 345,000 the prior week, the Labor Department reported Thursday. The four-week moving average, which smooths out weekly volatility in the data, fell to 339,500, also a pandemic low.

Claims have trended lower since mid-July, a sign employers are holding on to workers despite a rise in coronavirus cases tied to the spread of the Delta variant in many parts of the U.S. and weaker-than-expected job growth in August.

“We are not seeing regular initial claims spike, so that would imply that the Delta variant isn’t causing massive layoffs like we saw at the beginning of Covid,” said AnnElizabeth Konkel, economist at the jobs website Indeed.

Ms. Konkel said the rise in Covid-19 cases could yet show up in the claims data. “We’re still at the mercy of the pandemic,” she said.

The increase in cases has weighed on consumer sentiment and appeared to contribute to the hiring slowdown last month, particularly in the leisure and hospitality industry.

While claims are down sharply from levels earlier this year, they remain nearly 100,000 above their pre-pandemic trend. Weekly claims averaged 218,000 in 2019. More broadly, the economy had roughly 5.3 million fewer jobs in August compared with the pandemic’s onset in February 2020.

“All in all, jobless claims data point to a solid pace for job growth, although as the August payroll data underscore, the path may not always be a smooth one,” said Joshua Shapiro, chief U.S. economist at Maria Fiorini Ramirez, in a note to clients.

Employers nationwide have reported difficulty in filling job openings, which have leveled off at records, while millions of Americans remain unemployed.

Sarah House, senior economist at Wells Fargo, said that difficulty could be one reason initial jobless claims have continued falling despite employers reporting that the Delta variant is injecting renewed uncertainty into their plans.

“I think you have employers holding on to the workers that they have, given that they know how hard it is to go out there and hire right now,” Ms. House said. “If you’re playing the long game and you know how long it takes to hire workers, then you likely wait this one out,” she added.

Sept. 6 marked the expiration of enhanced unemployment benefits for many Americans, such as a $300 weekly supplement to regular state benefits that was included in government pandemic aid. About half of U.S. states had opted to end their participation earlier this summer.

States that ended the programs early have so far seen about the same rate of job growth as those that didn’t. Americans filed roughly 11.9 million ongoing claims for unemployment benefits through all programs, including two special pandemic programs, during the week ended Aug. 21, the most recent data available.

Any substantial impact from the termination of the special pandemic programs isn’t likely to show up in the claims data for several weeks, economists said. The Labor and Treasury departments have said states can turn to $350 billion in funds allocated to them from a Covid-19 aid package to continue providing additional unemployment assistance to workers. So far, states aren’t taking the Biden administration up on the extension option, Oxford Economics said in a client note Thursday.

Ms. House said child-care concerns and some Americans’ fear of contracting the coronavirus likely remain factors contributing to employers’ difficulties hiring. Still, she said robust demand for workers was one sign the labor market recovery remained on track overall, despite the lackluster August jobs report.

“The prospects for the labor market recovery remain very strong, but supply continues to be the biggest holdup right now,” she said.