Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Plan to limit proxies one can hold at condo meetings

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    10,829

    Default Plan to limit proxies one can hold at condo meetings

    http://www.straitstimes.com/business...condo-meetings

    Plan to limit proxies one can hold at condo meetings

    Feb 2, 2017

    Proposed change aims to tackle use of proxy votes to push certain owners' agenda

    Lee Xin En


    Proxy wars at condominium general meetings - where some owners gather hundreds of proxy votes to try to push their own agenda - could become a thing of the past.

    To tackle the problem, the Building and Construction Authority (BCA) is proposing to limit the number of proxies that any one person is permitted to hold.

    The agency said yesterday it is conducting its third and final consultation on the review of the Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act which governs the management and maintenance of strata-titled properties, such as condos.

    A BCA spokesman said the final public consultation, to end on Feb 21, includes new proposed amendments raised from previous rounds of consultation.

    The draft amendments aim to enhance governance and transparency over how strata-titled developments are run, and to provide more clarity on some of the provisions.

    The most notable change would involve a limit on the number of proxies one can hold. Currently, a unit owner can appoint a proxy to represent him to vote at a general meeting - with no restriction on the number of proxies a person can hold.

    The amendment would cap the number of proxies at either 2 per cent of the total number of lots in the development or two subsidiary proprietors, also known as unit owners, whichever is the higher figure, in a strata-titled project.

    Industry watchers cheered the proposed amendments.

    Ms Winnie Wong, deputy managing director at Savills Property Management, said that the proposal was a "good development".

    There have "always been complaints by subsidiary proprietors at general meetings that another subsidiary proprietor holding a lot of proxies will be controlling the decisions made at the general meeting".

    Most owners who collect proxies typically want to vote for or against collective sales or by-laws such as the charging for parking of a second vehicle, she said.

    Mr Jimmie Ling of the Association of Management Corporations in Singapore said he has advised at least 10 management councils over such proxy-collecting owners.

    "With unlimited proxies, people can push for their personal agenda. For people who feel that they are at the losing end, I usually tell them to do the same thing - collect your own proxies - but it's not so simple a thing to do."

    Mr Ling added that the most number of proxies he had seen was an individual holding 250 proxies.

    He said allowing a 2 per cent cap on proxies would only "minimise" the problem, but not eradicate the dominance of certain individuals.

    As many condos are large, a few people forming a group and collecting 2 per cent of total unit holders each could still wield a significant amount of influence, he said.

    Mr Alan Tang, a management council member in a condo, backed the change. "Whichever side you are on, I think this amendment creates fairness," he said.

    However, he added that the limit on proxies could cause residents who cannot attend the general meeting to be unable to find a person who can hold his proxy.

    Dr Lim Lan Yuan, president of the Association of Property and Facility Managers, noted that the cap on proxies could cause issues, such as not being able to pass an amendment that could genuinely improve the development's assets.

    However, the potential disadvantages were minor against the advantages of the proposed amendments, which would bring greater transparency and fairness.

    Another proposal ensures the old management council passes on relevant documents to the new council. Failure to do so will be an offence.

    Another prohibits a council member who holds the position of treasurer from concurrently being chairman or secretary - to encourage the separation of powers.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    10,829

    Default Proposed strata rule changes a nod to governance and transparency

    http://www.businesstimes.com.sg/real...d-transparency

    Proposed strata rule changes a nod to governance and transparency

    Thursday, February 2, 2017

    by Lynette Khoo
    [email protected]
    @LynetteKhooBT


    PROPOSED changes to the law that governs the management and maintenance of strata properties here were announced on Wednesday, aimed at improving the governance and transparency in the management of strata-titled developments, and providing greater clarity to existing provisions.

    Chief among the proposals is a cap on the number of proxies one can hold during a general meeting, to prevent abuse by those who garner proxy votes to influence decision-making; allowing management corporations - commonly known as MCSTs (Management Corporation Strata Title) - the option to pay honorarium to council members; and defining what constitutes common property.

    One other proposed change seeks to allow owners to install safety grilles to protect children where there are no design guidelines for the development.

    Market watchers note that amendments to the Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act (BMSMA) will help to remove ambiguities in existing provisions and address recurring issues that cropped up in past disputes between MCSTs and owners of strata units.
    SEE ALSO: Public sector projects to boost construction demand in 2017

    Melvin Chan, TSMP Law Corporation's head of litigation and dispute resolution, said: "These proposed changes tighten up the way the MCST is run. They also codify what has been stated by the Court in past disputes.

    "Some areas that were unclear and subject to the discretion of the MCST have become clearer," he added.

    Lee & Lee's senior partner for litigation and dispute resolution Toh Kok Seng felt that the proposal to limit the number of proxies for each person to either 2 per cent of total lots in a development or two owners - whichever is higher - is a step in the right direction. This would make it harder for a single owner to collect numerous proxies to out-vote others.

    Eleana Teo, managing director of Knight Frank Property Asset Management (strata management), however, is concerned that some owners may still game the system by redistributing the proxies to more persons.

    She flagged that one proposed amendment that may affect developers is the requirement for them to seek the approval on the amount of maintenance charges before selling any strata lot.

    While this may provide more clarity for property buyers, it is not easy for developers to accurately estimate the actual maintenance charges for projects to be completed two to three years' later, having to factor in wage inflation, said Ms Teo.

    But this proposed change to the Act is not without reason. Mr Toh said he has lately come across cases where buyers are upset that the actual amount of maintenance charges they are made to pay is significantly higher than the estimated amount at the time of purchase.

    CBRE associate director for asset services Serene Koh felt that the Act then has to address how the approved maintenance fund can be adjusted, if it turns out to be insufficient.

    She felt that there could also be more clarity on other sections of the Act. For instance, the Act is silent on how potential income from common areas can be used to offset operating expenses and reduce the contribution to the maintenance fund.

    "Such income, particularly from car parks in commercial developments, can be a substantial amount," she said.

    Industry players generally welcome the proposed definition of "common property" in the BMSMA to include key structural elements of the building, following court cases in recent years that took issue with the ambiguity of the current definition.

    One case saw the management corporation of Highpoint in Mount Elizabeth taking a couple to the Strata Titles Board (STB), after they claimed they were not responsible for repairing cracks in the ceiling above their kitchen and bedroom toilet. The High Court ruling later clarified in 2014 that condo unit owners are not responsible for repairing defects in structural beams above their properties.

    The proposed provision for owners to install safety grilles in their units is also widely hailed by industry players, given the several skirmishes between the MCST and residents when the residents were prevented from installing safety grilles to prevent harm to children.

    Mr Toh noted that it is necessary to make this clear in legislation, as there are still MCSTs that refuse to allow safety grilles in balconies, even though the STB had ruled in the case of One North Residences in 2015 to allow an owner to install safety grilles in his balcony, and public opinion that supports putting safety ahead of appearance.

    Lee Liat Yeang, senior partner at Dentons Rodyk, noted that it is progressive to adopt the proposed amendment to allow strata rolls to be kept in electronic forms, and to allow notices to be served by electronic mail. "This will enable timely dissemination of information. It is also interesting to allow audio/virtual conferencing for Council meetings," he added, citing increased reliance on technology to facilitate communication.

    In all, a total of 33 items were listed in the proposed amendments to the BMSMA. A spokeswoman from the Building and Construction Authority (BCA) on Wednesday told BT that these amendments are proposed as part of BCA's regular review of the legislations to ensure that they are relevant to current needs.

    This will mark the first revision to the Act since the BMSMA came into force in April 2005. A final public consultation round, which followed two earlier rounds since 2012, will end on Feb 21.

    BCA said it has sought the views of stakeholders such as the industry associations, developers, lawyers, academics, managing agents, subsidiary proprietors and council members of MCSTs. It is gathering further feedback on the consolidated list of amendments before finalising the legislative changes. The effective date of the amendments will be announced when the draft Bill is tabled and read in Parliament.

    "As the BMSMA has a wide impact on strata-titled developments, there was a need to carry out a comprehensive and robust review, providing all stakeholders the opportunity to give feedback, comments and suggestion on changes needed to improve strata living," the BCA spokeswoman said.


Similar Threads

  1. MinLaw to curb number of owners a proxy can represent at meetings on enbloc sales
    By New Reporter in forum En Bloc Discussion and News
    Replies: 0
    -: 01-10-20, 18:13
  2. Condo, HDB rental volumes tumble in August; rents hold: SRX
    By New Reporter in forum Singapore Private Condominium Property Discussion and News
    Replies: 0
    -: 09-09-20, 20:32
  3. hold or sell my investment condo property
    By NANALUM89 in forum Singapore Private Condominium Property Discussion and News
    Replies: 18
    -: 09-06-20, 15:07
  4. Tackling abuse of proxy votes at estate general meetings
    By reporter2 in forum En Bloc Discussion and News
    Replies: 12
    -: 17-09-13, 10:58
  5. Condo man dominated AGM with 80 proxies
    By mr funny in forum Singapore Private Condominium Property Discussion and News
    Replies: 1
    -: 04-07-07, 14:58

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •