Originally Posted by
get your facts right
Shelford is NOT, and I repeat NOT at the fringe of D11.
Shelford is located right smack in the middle of D11 Bukit Timah, just opposite D10 Coronation and Duchess area.
If you want to talk about fringe, then Swiss Club Road will be the fringe of D11 bordering D21.
Newton and Novena may be classified under D11, but in the past, when people talked about D10/11 prime property they were usually talking about the Bukit Timah/Dunearn/Stevens/Whitley/Trevose/Duchess/Shelford/Watten/Sixth Ave stretch. These were usually landed houses where the upper class lived, including several Mnisters, property magnate Mr Ng, banking tycoon Mr Wee, and the various prominent Tans, Lees and Lims. It was absolutely not a coincidence that all the elite schools were located here in D10/11 Bukit Timah as well.
It was only recently that Newton and Novena gained recognition as a "prime" D11 area, with condo-living becoming popular. In the past Newton and Novena was all ulu land prone to flooding (and thus rendered uninhabitable), before they expanded the canal to accomodate the floodwaters.
If you can match the old postal codes to the current locations, you may be able to better understand what Bukit Timah is all about. 1026, 1027, 1128, 1129, 1130. You know where 1130 is? Newton/Novena, which will be the nearest to District 12 Moulmein and Balestier.
1128 is the Swiss Club stretch down to Shelford. 1129 covers Adam, University Rd, Trevose Crescent, Whitley, Swiss Cottage. 1130 starts from Goldhill, Chancery onwards past Barker Rd to Newton/Novena....traditionally not a very prime area as it is close to the slums of KK Hospital, Moulmein, and Balestier.
Why did they zone it like that? It is obvious that 1128 is a continuation of 1027. Imagine you go up Bukit Timah to the Sixth Avenue entrance, past Tan Chong Motor then immediately make a U-Turn back across the canal along Dunearn Road at Swiss Club Rd, then down past Eng Neo, Hillcrest, NJC, Watten, then you enter the 1129 realm of Trevose and Whitley. This was the traditional prime stomping ground of the old upper and upper middle class.
You do not know what Prime is, my friend. Prime is not several generic tall glass buildings squeezed together like HDB blocks.
If you don't know what you are talking about then do us all a favour, shut up, and stop displaying your ignorance here.