PDA

View Full Version : Economy bad? Still buying?



Joffrey
25-11-16, 10:10
Economy is bad which I read from Hwz. My wife and I still hopeful to get 2nd property and be a landlord so we could upgrade and rent out our flat. What is the real situation out there now? Will there be rental demand? or we are in bad shape now?

Our household income has reduced to 5k+. My wife just got retrenched earlier this month. Should we go ahead with another small property? Flat still has outstanding loan of 400k and we have saving of around 300k+.

Ginola
25-11-16, 10:36
Economy is bad which I read from Hwz. My wife and I still hopeful to get 2nd property and be a landlord so we could upgrade and rent out our flat. What is the real situation out there now? Will there be rental demand? or we are in bad shape now?

Our household income has reduced to 5k+. My wife just got retrenched earlier this month. Should we go ahead with another small property? Flat still has outstanding loan of 400k and we have saving of around 300k+.


I am not a guru in property. My opinion is that if you wish to get a 2nd property, you should clear off your first loan so that you can get 80% loan for your 2nd property. Do also consider the 7% ABSD on your 2nd property. Good luck!

Kelonguni
25-11-16, 10:45
It's a good time to buy only for those with sufficient buffers.

Your situation quite precarious unless your Wife and yourself can buy and live in a MM unit with mortgage fully covered by projected rent from HDB.

Rental rates quite soft now and you should be a little defensive with single income.



Economy is bad which I read from Hwz. My wife and I still hopeful to get 2nd property and be a landlord so we could upgrade and rent out our flat. What is the real situation out there now? Will there be rental demand? or we are in bad shape now?

Our household income has reduced to 5k+. My wife just got retrenched earlier this month. Should we go ahead with another small property? Flat still has outstanding loan of 400k and we have saving of around 300k+.

indomie
25-11-16, 11:51
If your goal to preserve wealth, you should buy now. If your goal to create wealth you should hold.

DMCK
25-11-16, 13:10
don't get yourself into shit

Arcachon
25-11-16, 14:41
Not enough info.

Age of you and your wife.

What is your first property

How many cherry taken.

How much did you pay for the first property.

More info more accurate advise, less info good luck to you with the advise.

Newbie1
25-11-16, 18:51
If your goal to preserve wealth, you should buy now. If your goal to create wealth you should hold.

Er.....what is the difference between the 2?

Thought they should be interlinked

Maybe say buy to stay or buy for investment

Joffrey
25-11-16, 19:04
Not enough info.

Age of you and your wife.

What is your first property

How many cherry taken.

How much did you pay for the first property.

More info more accurate advise, less info good luck to you with the advise.

I am 40 and my wife is 38.
Our current property is HDB 4 room flat, bought resales.
We paid around 480k for the flat in Jurong East.
We have two kids 2 and 4 years old.

cbsh38584
25-11-16, 19:24
I am 40 and my wife is 38.
Our current property is HDB 4 room flat, bought resales.
We paid around 480k for the flat in Jurong East.
We have two kids 2 and 4 years old.

Base on the info you have provided. Initially, I cant believe you may still want to consider buying a 2nd ppty when your wife has just been retrenched.
Now, It make me "BOIL" when you said that you have 2 kids.

Arcachon
25-11-16, 21:23
Base on the info you have provided. Initially, I cant believe you may still want to consider buying a 2nd ppty when your wife has just been retrenched.
Now, It make me "BOIL" when you said that you have 2 kids.

Relax, more info more accurate advise, less info can only say good luck to the advise given.

Arcachon
25-11-16, 21:26
I am 40 and my wife is 38.
Our current property is HDB 4 room flat, bought resales.
We paid around 480k for the flat in Jurong East.
We have two kids 2 and 4 years old.

Base on the above, my personal view is go for BTO than Private.

Can also go for new EC.

Arcachon
25-11-16, 21:30
Er.....what is the difference between the 2?

Thought they should be interlinked

Maybe say buy to stay or buy for investment

preserve wealth means buy for rental income

create wealth means capital appreciation (when everyone is fearful)

Arcachon
25-11-16, 21:44
Please remember to have only one owner to the HDB or EC property and the other as occupier so as to have reduced Stamp Duty for the next purchase.

indomie
25-11-16, 22:14
Er.....what is the difference between the 2?

Thought they should be interlinked

Maybe say buy to stay or buy for investment

Preserving wealth is when u have cash equivalent of more than 50% of the property u want to buy.
Creating wealth is when u have less than 30% in cash of the property u want to buy.

Preserving weath is defensive strategy, whereas creating wealth is aggressive strategy.

Kelonguni
25-11-16, 22:47
With 2 kids MM is quite out of equation.

If I were in your shoes will not do anything or try to gun for the most valued and biggest BTO that I could afford. Preferably sales of balance flats that are about to complete. Jurong east 4rm is a very good long term proposition too if stay put.

Cannot hoard status hoard the space first. Be patient and wait for future opportunities.



I am 40 and my wife is 38.
Our current property is HDB 4 room flat, bought resales.
We paid around 480k for the flat in Jurong East.
We have two kids 2 and 4 years old.

cbsh38584
26-11-16, 08:21
I am 40 and my wife is 38.
Our current property is HDB 4 room flat, bought resales.
We paid around 480k for the flat in Jurong East.
We have two kids 2 and 4 years old.

Buying or upgrading is NOT A GAME OF CARD for a married man especially with 2 young kids. This is your whole family life at stake.
Your parent & both of you have worked & saved 20 yrs + to have a decent living in HDB.

As long as you are the MAN IN CHARGE, you need to ensure your family financial health did not deteriorate. You need to be very prudent
and not to get your whole amily in deep shit. Nobody is going to KNOCK IT DOWN what you have achieved unless you yourself.

From what you have provided. You use less cash & more CPF for your housing purchased. So u end up with more liquid cash avail.
Now with more liquid cash avail, like most of them. U will either want to have more holiday or buy car or upgrading to EC or CONDO etc.
They have forgotten about the future retirement. CPF is one of the best scheme avail for your retirement.Now if your CASH investment turn
bad or did not perform . You will not see the problem now. But when u reach 50s, you will know it & will regret it.

Arcachon
27-11-16, 07:48
He is right and I also agree, CPF is for retirement. I only use it to buy HDB for a loan of 200,000 I need to pay back CPF about 300,000

teddybear
27-11-16, 09:54
"CPF is one of the best scheme avail for your retirement."??? ha ha ha! :hopelessness:

Only "best" for financial idiots, that is what I can say....... :topsy_turvy:


Buying or upgrading is NOT A GAME OF CARD for a married man especially with 2 young kids. This is your whole family life at stake.
Your parent & both of you have worked & saved 20 yrs + to have a decent living in HDB.

As long as you are the MAN IN CHARGE, you need to ensure your family financial health did not deteriorate. You need to be very prudent
and not to get your whole amily in deep shit. Nobody is going to KNOCK IT DOWN what you have achieved unless you yourself.

From what you have provided. You use less cash & more CPF for your housing purchased. So u end up with more liquid cash avail.
Now with more liquid cash avail, like most of them. U will either want to have more holiday or buy car or upgrading to EC or CONDO etc.
They have forgotten about the future retirement. CPF is one of the best scheme avail for your retirement.Now if your CASH investment turn
bad or did not perform . You will not see the problem now. But when u reach 50s, you will know it & will regret it.

Kelonguni
27-11-16, 09:55
He is right and I also agree, CPF is for retirement. I only use it to buy HDB for a loan of 200,000 I need to pay back CPF about 300,000

300,000 is based on principal CPF sum plus accrued interest (based on 2.5%).

How much can you exchange the HDB for now?

star
28-11-16, 08:39
Is the $300k including CPF? How much in your ordinary CPF account?

Arcachon
28-11-16, 09:42
Long time no see my CPF, time for me get a update.

teddybear
28-11-16, 11:23
Singapore is going in recession soon, and with it will crash Singapore OCR private property prices because they are still at historical HIGH (while exerting some additional downside to CCR which has already crashed)............
So you wanna buy now?
Please go ahead, but be warned and take heed! :cat:

10 years from now, please look back and see what we have said/warned!


Economy is bad which I read from Hwz. My wife and I still hopeful to get 2nd property and be a landlord so we could upgrade and rent out our flat. What is the real situation out there now? Will there be rental demand? or we are in bad shape now?

Our household income has reduced to 5k+. My wife just got retrenched earlier this month. Should we go ahead with another small property? Flat still has outstanding loan of 400k and we have saving of around 300k+.

Kelonguni
28-11-16, 13:23
Dunno if it's a coincidence that Joffrey and Yowe sounds so similar. Their stance also quite the same, the innocent lemmings kind...

Just read with a pinch of salt like you said. Relax.



Singapore is going in recession soon, and with it will crash Singapore OCR private property prices because they are still at historical HIGH (while exerting some additional downside to CCR which has already crashed)............
So you wanna buy now?
Please go ahead, but be warned and take heed! :cat:

10 years from now, please look back and see what we have said/warned!

august
28-11-16, 15:00
CPF should not be used for property purchase, period. Then we can start talking about "best scheme for retirement ever".

teddybear
28-11-16, 15:34
I don't see how CPF should not be used for property purchase, since property is a good investment for long-term inflation hedge, if they buy the right one at the right price.

Anyway, for retirement, it is all the more important that people use their CPF to invest, be it in property, stocks, etc.
They should just invest over a long term (instead of keeping them as cash in CPF), and they should have more high-return investment choices! (rather than just being restricted to 30% in stocks and must be stocks listed on the Singapore mickey mouse exchange, or 100% in unit trusts when they can just get milked by high expenses for CPF-OA!)
Worse still, CPF-SA can only invest in those Unit Trusts again! (so that these people can be milked with high expenses charged by Unit Trust Managers???)

Or alternative, people should be compensated with higher interest for their CPF money (because of compulsory lock-in of their money and few good investment choice because of too many restrictions!).

The problem is that: Most people are financial idiots, and they don't know how to invest!

Firstly, they use CPF money anyhow buy stocks, get burnt!
Then they use CPF money to buy unit trusts or ILPs, they got milked (by the high expenses)!
Then they use CPF money to buy OCR private properties, like now at the HISTORICAL PEAK price!

Like that sure lose money right? If they don't, they must be super lucky!
But luck usually will never be with anybody all the time!


CPF should not be used for property purchase, period. Then we can start talking about "best scheme for retirement ever".

Arcachon
28-11-16, 19:37
Is the $300k including CPF? How much in your ordinary CPF account?

Did not know I so low pay.

Ordinary Account (OA) $128,289.61
Special Account (SA) $113,035.74
Medisave Account (MA) $49,796.17

$1,020.00. (*OA: $413.62 *SA: $317.01 *MA: $289.37)

$189,820.72 Net Amount Used
$ 70,680.29 Accrued Interest
$260,501.01 Total

Date Of Application 25 Oct 1993
Date Of Purchase 01 Nov 1995
Purchase Price $225,600
Loan Commencement Date Nov 1995
Loan Expiry Date Oct 2020
Interest Rate (p.a.) * 2.60% (Concessionary)

Monthly Instalment $923.00
I pay $600
Wife pays $263

If you pay off your mortgage of $41,168.80, your interest savings will be $2,174.80.
3 years 11 months