PDA

View Full Version : Large EC units may be a tough sell following MSR ruling



princess_morbucks
13-12-13, 21:23
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/singapore/large-ec-units-may-be-a/921452.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter
SINGAPORE: Property agents expect larger executive condominium (EC) units to be a tough sell following the implementation of the 30 per cent Mortgage Servicing Ratio (MSR) on December 10.

Seven executive condominium projects were launched for sale in 2013. They offer a total of 3,337 units, of which 2,337 have been sold as of December 10.

Of the remaining units, agents say 48 per cent are larger 4- and 5-bedroom apartments, which could cost close to or above S$1 million.

Sales of these units could be hurt with the new MSR which is capped at 30 per cent of the borrower's monthly income, affecting his or her ability to buy more expensive units.

Some analysts estimate that a household with a combined income of S$12,000 can probably afford an EC unit costing around S$1 million, assuming they take an 80 per cent loan over 30 years.

The EC projects with the largest balance stock of large units are Waterwoods in Punggol with a total of 147 four- and five-room apartments, SkyPark Residences at Sembawang with 135 apartments, and Sea Horizon at Paris Ris with 95 apartments.

They are the last three projects to be launched in 2013.

Property agents say the impact on sales will likely be felt in the next one to two months as the market comes to terms with the new MSR, and that developers of new EC projects will have to be creative in right-sizing the units to drive sales.

"The smaller units, like the 2-bedrooms and the 3-rooms that are probably in the region of 980 square feet to less than 1100 square feet -- those are receiving quite well (response). They are still within the affordability level. So going forward, I think developers may consider to build these sizes again," said GPS Alliance CEO Jeffrey Hong.

Meanwhile, prices of ECs are not likely to fall immediately. However, industry players see a more stable price trend in the second half of 2014 when new EC projects are expected to be launched.

"Before the implementation of MSR, there is a possibility that EC prices may move up further from $800 per square foot (psf) to $850, even $900 psf,” said OrangeTee managing director Steven Tan. “Because this is the only market that is not affected by the TDSR (Total Debt Servicing Ratio)."

"Now with this MSR, definitely the market uptrend will be controlled and there will be a stabilising effect -- probably it will go back to the price level of maybe S$750-800 psf. For some good locations, it could still be above S$800 psf."

In January 2013, the government announced a new requirement that EC developers will only be able to market their projects 15 months from the date of award of the sites.

Analysts say the new rules will encourage developers to be more cautious with their land bids and to better manage cost.

rymccondo77
13-12-13, 21:40
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/singapore/large-ec-units-may-be-a/921452.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter
SINGAPORE: Property agents expect larger executive condominium (EC) units to be a tough sell following the implementation of the 30 per cent Mortgage Servicing Ratio (MSR) on December 10.

Seven executive condominium projects were launched for sale in 2013. They offer a total of 3,337 units, of which 2,337 have been sold as of December 10.

Of the remaining units, agents say 48 per cent are larger 4- and 5-bedroom apartments, which could cost close to or above S$1 million.

Sales of these units could be hurt with the new MSR which is capped at 30 per cent of the borrower's monthly income, affecting his or her ability to buy more expensive units.

Some analysts estimate that a household with a combined income of S$12,000 can probably afford an EC unit costing around S$1 million, assuming they take an 80 per cent loan over 30 years.

The EC projects with the largest balance stock of large units are Waterwoods in Punggol with a total of 147 four- and five-room apartments, SkyPark Residences at Sembawang with 135 apartments, and Sea Horizon at Paris Ris with 95 apartments.

They are the last three projects to be launched in 2013.

Property agents say the impact on sales will likely be felt in the next one to two months as the market comes to terms with the new MSR, and that developers of new EC projects will have to be creative in right-sizing the units to drive sales.

"The smaller units, like the 2-bedrooms and the 3-rooms that are probably in the region of 980 square feet to less than 1100 square feet -- those are receiving quite well (response). They are still within the affordability level. So going forward, I think developers may consider to build these sizes again," said GPS Alliance CEO Jeffrey Hong.

Meanwhile, prices of ECs are not likely to fall immediately. However, industry players see a more stable price trend in the second half of 2014 when new EC projects are expected to be launched.

"Before the implementation of MSR, there is a possibility that EC prices may move up further from $800 per square foot (psf) to $850, even $900 psf,” said OrangeTee managing director Steven Tan. “Because this is the only market that is not affected by the TDSR (Total Debt Servicing Ratio)."

"Now with this MSR, definitely the market uptrend will be controlled and there will be a stabilising effect -- probably it will go back to the price level of maybe S$750-800 psf. For some good locations, it could still be above S$800 psf."

In January 2013, the government announced a new requirement that EC developers will only be able to market their projects 15 months from the date of award of the sites.

Analysts say the new rules will encourage developers to be more cautious with their land bids and to better manage cost.

Error in the article - "Sea Horizon at Paris Ris with 95 apartments" ... :D

radha08
14-12-13, 03:00
just come out with a cm that maximum ec size cannot exceed 1200sq ft simple :doh:.....30% tdsr with 12k income ceiling is a joke:doh::doh::doh:

radha08
14-12-13, 03:02
ec=eXtremely controlled:doh:

4wheels
14-12-13, 05:42
Error in the article - "Sea Horizon at Paris Ris with 95 apartments" ... :D

Don't think is error. The report is referring to 4 to 5 bedders units that are unsold.

RCT
14-12-13, 05:47
Don't think is error. The report is referring to 4 to 5 bedders units that are unsold.

This is to show you that the market in Singapore is extremely control. Still have 1k plus EC have not been sold? I am quite surprised with that numbers. I though from the news it seems that the sales is very good and all have been sold out. Now EC will have a big problem.

RCT
14-12-13, 05:48
just come out with a cm that maximum ec size cannot exceed 1200sq ft simple :doh:.....30% tdsr with 12k income ceiling is a joke:doh::doh::doh:

Why max out the size? Maybe some rich people want to buy? Earn 12k income but have 1 million cash in hand.

hyenergix
14-12-13, 06:46
I believe HDB to EC upgraders are quite rich, and can afford the downpayment to meet the MSR. The only issue they are spoilt for choice now. Location is still the key. The sweet spot could be compact 3/4-bedders for multiple-generation living as maids are increasingly more expensive and unreliable.

Douk
14-12-13, 08:59
Not all middle class are equal..

NO_7
14-12-13, 10:30
MSR only apply to new launches, rite?
After MOP will follow private ppty rule?

el loco
14-12-13, 10:50
Don't think is error. The report is referring to 4 to 5 bedders units that are unsold.

The error is in the spelling...Pasir Ris and not PARIS Ris...haha

radha08
14-12-13, 12:44
I believe HDB to EC upgraders are quite rich, and can afford the downpayment to meet the MSR. The only issue they are spoilt for choice now. Location is still the key. The sweet spot could be compact 3/4-bedders for multiple-generation living as maids are increasingly more expensive and unreliable.

if they are rich why buy ec:confused:
keep the hdb and buy pc:2cents::cheers1:

newbie11
14-12-13, 13:45
Maybe they will buy resale EC now. Can be cheaper and bigger than new EC, no mop, no msr.

玉格格
14-12-13, 18:08
Maybe they will buy resale EC now. Can be cheaper and bigger than new EC, no mop, no msr.

After 5 yrs mop is still not considered pc rite?
actually now wif the msr, the whole ec scheme sounds very stupid.
half way after one service the loan liao, msr of 30% will become 60% tdsr when the ec privatise?

in the 1st place, ec shdnt even exist.
I dunno y ec is still allowed to continue.
using taxpayers $ to subsidize the wrong class! :doh:

teddybear
14-12-13, 19:45
Yah lor, HDB cater to 85% of citizens, EC cater for what % of citizens? Why still need to subsidize them using tax payers money when they are already in high income bracket and they already can afford a PC? :doh:


After 5 yrs mop is still not considered pc rite?
actually now wif the msr, the whole ec scheme sounds very stupid.
half way after one service the loan liao, msr of 30% will become 60% tdsr when the ec privatise?

in the 1st place, ec shdnt even exist.
I dunno y ec is still allowed to continue.
using taxpayers $ to subsidize the wrong class! :doh:

wt_know
14-12-13, 20:55
large EC is a joke in the first place
before the ruling ... developers are pushing EC size above 2000sqft for penthouses and 1200-1500sqft for large units
created a speculative markets and pushing owners to exceed their affordability limits

玉格格
14-12-13, 21:20
Yah lor, HDB cater to 85% of citizens, EC cater for what % of citizens? Why still need to subsidize them using tax payers money when they are already in high income bracket and they already can afford a PC? :doh:

yayalor, those who bought pc shdnt be penalised to subsidise so many category of ppl!
pls lor, couple earn 10k-12k is aldy alot, they dun nid subsidy la.
I earn much lesser den them leh but i bought pc. who will subsidise me? :(

rymccondo77
15-12-13, 00:23
The error is in the spelling...Pasir Ris and not PARIS Ris...haha

Yes, was referring to the error in the word PARIS Ris :D