PDA

View Full Version : 'Cut frills' to keep HDB flat prices down



reporter2
27-03-13, 15:28
http://www.straitstimes.com/archive/friday/premium/singapore/story/cut-frills-keep-hdb-flat-prices-down-20130322

'Cut frills' to keep HDB flat prices down

Instead of copying condos, allow for bigger flat area to plan homes: Ex-HDB chief

Published on Mar 22, 2013

By Daryl Chin Property Correspondent


PUBLIC housing flats can be kept affordable by offering them with minimum frills, rather than by trying to emulate condominiums, a former Housing Board chief said yesterday.

Mr Liu Thai Ker stressed that at the same time, owners should be given as much floor area as possible so that they have more leeway to organise their homes. The 74-year-old, a former HDB chief architect and chief executive officer, said: "The HDB's role is to provide the stage and it's up to the inhabitants to provide the drama."

Mr Liu was speaking to reporters after giving a talk at the Ministry of National Development headquarters covering his 20-year career with the HDB, which he left in 1989 after overseeing the development of 24 new towns and more than half a million HDB homes. In his talk, he added that beauty could still be created by playing around with the proportions and the colours of HDB blocks.

National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan has promised to bring down the prices of flats in non-mature estates to four times the annual household median income of its applicants. Last year, prices were about 51/2 times the annual household median income.

Among the suggestions floated by Mr Khaw is to have longer occupancy periods for new owners, shorter leases and even selling new flats back to HDB.

During Mr Liu's stint, when flats cost less than three times an applicant's annual income, the HDB matched selling prices to the economy's growth and the income of buyers eligible for public housing.

But as the property market developed, the HDB moved towards a market-based pricing approach which pegs new flats to comparable resale units but with a discount.

To keep new build-to-order flats within reach, Mr Khaw has delinked them from the resale market since taking over the housing portfolio in 2011.

Applauding the move, Mr Liu said the pricing of BTO flats should stand on its own. He added: "If we do this part of the work well, and with timely supply, the resale market will adjust itself."

HDB resale prices have hit record highs, driven by low interest rates and strong demand.

Mr Liu also suggested having a "marginal oversupply" of several hundred units in order to control resale flat prices and ensure demand is being met. Last year, Mr Khaw hinted that he may do just that once the current backlog of demand has been sated, although he added that it might be costly.

Mr Liu added that while doing all this, it was also important to ensure that the Government's finances remained sound. "If the Government is bankrupt, nothing can happen," he said.

Each empty flat is estimated to cost HDB about $10,000 each year in interest and maintenance.

[email protected]

pod
27-03-13, 16:04
Agree to keep HDB blocks & surrounding simple and easy in maintenance cost.

Seem too many 'new' estates with fancy interlocking road tiles that pops up after afew years. (regular road tarmac should suffice imo)

Huge landscape and planters around estate sometimes even blocking the view of drivers whilst manouevering around the estates. (sometimes even the BLK numbers are obstructed)

Fanciful steel structures that end up as laundry collection 'hooks' when clothes fly off from upstairs.

Roofgarden courts - badminton? I mean seriously, how can anyone play badminton with such strong winds? lol

etc etc

thomastansb
27-03-13, 16:39
You build cheap hdb with no facilities, people will complain that they need to spend additional money on tiles, doors etc. Then they will start writing to their MP to ask for gardens because their neighbours have gardens. Never ending one.

minority
27-03-13, 17:07
no play ground loh, no kopi tiam facility not so many roads to the estate or park lor.. no frills. mah.. but people will KPKB say how to live!!! it is not Frills they dont want no frills. they cant cheap !!!! Frills yes just not they pay!

also dont build the car park so near cenatralized it far away lor. save car park building cost too!

kane
27-03-13, 18:43
What frills are the referring to? Bto comes bare only with toilet done. Only dbss got all the condo like finishing.

phantom_opera
27-03-13, 20:33
easy, no corner unit .... no privacy, corrdior style HDB :rolleyes:

minority
27-03-13, 21:14
What frills are the referring to? Bto comes bare only with toilet done. Only dbss got all the condo like finishing.


surrounding support amenities are also fills.

kane
28-03-13, 00:24
surrounding support amenities are also fills.
A small tiny playground and exercise machines can't cost anymore than 1% of the current value for a cluster of say 300units right. How much savings can be achieve by cutting those 5 cent 10cent things.

Just kar kar cut land tenor lah. I really can't see how else we can drag the price of new flats down 30% without taking that route.

radha08
28-03-13, 00:30
HDB= Headache Development Board...:D:D:D

minority
28-03-13, 08:52
A small tiny playground and exercise machines can't cost anymore than 1% of the current value for a cluster of say 300units right. How much savings can be achieve by cutting those 5 cent 10cent things.

Just kar kar cut land tenor lah. I really can't see how else we can drag the price of new flats down 30% without taking that route.

That's raiding reserve. Are those reall 5c 10c? Not really. Must well say goverment provide building for free. Design of building be freeware concept public contribute . Labour to build we have the ns man do the job?