PDA

View Full Version : Highest state salary must not be 20 times more than the pay of the lowliest worker



richwang
01-06-12, 09:09
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/may/30/hollande-france-clamp-down-fat-cat-pay?newsfeed=true

Hollande to clamp down on fat cat pay

France's president has vowed that the highest state salary must not be 20 times more than the pay of the lowliest worker

Share (http://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=180444840287&link=http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/may/30/hollande-france-clamp-down-fat-cat-pay&display=popup&redirect_uri=http://static-serve.appspot.com/static/facebook-share/callback.html&show_error=false)921


http://static.guim.co.uk/static/b05b48a62321634f4c0395bffea3cb2437e98040/common/images/icon-email.pngEmail (http://www.guardian.co.uk/email/1753261)
Angelique Chrisafis (http://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/angeliquechrisafis) in Paris
guardian.co.uk (http://www.guardian.co.uk/), Wednesday 30 May 2012 19.05 BST
Comments (437) (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/may/30/hollande-france-clamp-down-fat-cat-pay#start-of-comments)http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Guardian/Pix/pictures/2012/5/30/1338401073544/French-President-Francois-009.jpg French president François Hollande has announced an immediate clampdown of executive pay at state-owned companies. Photograph: Rex Features

France's new socialist government has announced an immediate, dramatic clampdown on fat-cat pay, promising to cap the salaries of chief executives at state-owned companies which could see top pay-packages slashed or halved.
The president François Hollande (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/francois-hollande) vowed during the election campaign that in majority state-owned companies, the highest salary must not be 20 times more than the pay of the lowliest worker. The squeeze on state fat cats, expected to be enacted by decree next month, is part of the new government's quest for France to set a moral example in a crisis-hit Europe (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/europe-news) where top earners' stratospheric pay packages and benefits has exasperated workers and voters. The measure will sit alongside Hollande's promised new top tax rate of 75% on income over 1 million euros, which is extremely popular among the French public, and which he has described as an act of "patriotism" and "morality". Socialists brushed aside criticisms from the right that state pay-caps could make it difficult to recruit from private sector.
The prime minister Jean-Marc Ayrault, aware of the unease at fat-cat excesses weeks before the parliament elections, took a hard line, announcing in an interview with the weekly L'Express that the executive pay-cuts would apply to those already in their posts rather than only new contracts. "I believe in the patriotism of company leaders. They can understand the crisis requires the political and financial elite to set an example". The president and cabinet have cut their own pay by 30%.
The French state owns stakes in 52 companies, although only 23 are 100% state-owned, including the railway SNCF, the post office La Poste and various ports and airports. Companies where the state is a majority stake-holder, and which will be affected, include the energy giant EDF and nuclear power plant builder Areva, both currently expanding internationally including in Britain. Only companies controlled at more than 50% by the state will have to abide by pay changes. The state could also seek to pressure those where it has a minority stake, such as France Telecom, Air France and Renault, although there is no guarantee they must abide by government demands.
One of the biggest hits could be taken by Henri Proglio, the chief executive of EDF, who currently earns around 1.55m euros, 64 times the lowest paid electrician. Proglio might have to take a 68% pay cut and see his package dip below 500,000 euros. According to the daily Liberation, the chief executive of the French post office could also lose 41% of his package. On over 600,000 euros, he currently earns 34 times the wage of the lowliest postal worker. Guillaume Pepy, head of the railways, SNCF, earns an estimated 250,000, around 15 times the lowest-paid rail workers, so would not face a cut.
The finance minister Pierre Moscovici said a decree would be issued by cabinet within two weeks over the pay caps. But the state sought to send a clear message by announcing it would oppose a 400,000 euro indemnity payout to the former chief executive of the loss-making Air France, in which the state holds a 15.9% stake. "It's called decency in pay," said Arnaud Montebourg, the minister for Industrial Recovery.
Louis Gallois, outgoing chief executive of the European defence group EADS, in which the French government has a minority stake, said there shouldn't be "tears" on the part of executives, but told Europe 1 radio, "I do recognise it's steep for some." He added: "For me, it's a crisis measure, like the 75% tax on remuneration over one million euros … These are measures that should be provisional, an expression of a crisis situation and necessarily solidarity." He said in general, companies should be given more flexibility on setting pay.

Regulators
01-06-12, 13:15
our ministers' pay is more than 200 times the pay of a foodcourt cleaner's pay leh, like that where got justice?

hopeful
01-06-12, 14:13
why so selective?
do you also want govt to impose 75% tax?
you work 12 months, 7 months go to tax man, balance 5 months is for you.

Blue
01-06-12, 16:06
Sorry hor, in Europe, the folks dun work 12 months. They have long summer and winter vacations. Their medical benefits are well taken care of.

Allthepies
01-06-12, 21:40
Good life of most European citizens are coming to an end, no need to envy them any more... Just look at Greece...

Now the critical issue is that Singapore won't walk the path of Greece... We must keep our capable people within our economy at all means...

Remember always that the poor won't become rich by making the rich poor :tsk-tsk:

Justice? What justice? So many Africa people died of starvation every minutes while Singaporeans eating buffets and growing fat. Can we have justice and stop buffet eating in Singapore and limit Singaporeans to one bowl of rich per meal and one dish per meal?

hyenergix
01-06-12, 21:45
Good life of most European citizens are coming to an end, no need to envy them any more... Just look at Greece...

Now the critical issue is that Singapore won't walk the path of Greece... We must keep our capable people within our economy at all means...

Remember always that the poor won't become rich by making the rich poor :tsk-tsk:

WW III is coming at the end of Mayan's calender. Westerners are coming Asia to gold, money and women :eek:

hopeful
01-06-12, 21:48
WW III is coming at the end of Mayan's calender. Westerners are coming Asia to gold, money and women :eek:

what will happen to the Asian men?

Allthepies
01-06-12, 21:52
WW III is coming at the end of Mayan's calender. Westerners are coming Asia to gold, money and women :eek:

R western women coming here too to mine gold, money and Asian men? :D :D

howgozit
01-06-12, 23:10
Sorry hor, in Europe, the folks dun work 12 months. They have long summer and winter vacations. Their medical benefits are well taken care of.

So how long do you think they can hold this up?

richwang
02-06-12, 11:34
Rough comparision between Singapore marginal income tax and France's

http://www.french-property.com/news/tax_france/income_tax_rates_2012/

1 EURO = 1.6 SGD

Taxable Income Singapore France
0 - S$10k 0% 0%
S$10k - S$20K 0% 5.5%
S$20K - S$30K 2% 14%
S$30k - S$40K 3.5% 14%
S$40K - S$80K 7% 30%
S$80K - S$120K 11.5% 30%
S$120K - S$160K 15% 41%
S$160K - S$320K 17-18% 41%
S$320K - S$1.6M 20% 41%
> S$1.6M 20% 75% (soon)

Thanks,
Richard

roly8
02-06-12, 12:03
how can?

not easy to be primie minister leh:o